Divided into four sections, this episode tells the story of: the aftermath of Pacey and Joey's first night together, Jen's first therapy session, Dawson dealing with Mr. Brooks' death and later on, Joey and Dawson spend a relaxed evening hanging out.
- James Van Der Beek as Dawson Leery
- Katie Holmes as Joey Potter
- Michelle Williams as Jen Lindley
- Joshua Jackson as Pacey Witter
- Kerr Smith as Jack McPhee
- Mary Beth Peil as Evelyn Ryan
Special Guest Stars
- Rob Nagle as Tom Frost
- First appearance of Tom Frost
- Jen goes to therapy for the first time in her life
- Dawson flat out asks Joey if she slept with Pacey.
- Joey actually answers the intruding question, but lies.