- „Y'all can never be friends as long as you keep fighting over the same guy. Joey, it's obvious you're in love with Dawson”
- —Abby Morgan
TRUTH OR DARE -- Emotions run rampant I the halls of Capeside High when Dawson (James Van Der Beek), Joey (Katie Holmes), Jen (Michelle Williams) and Pacey (Joshua Jackson) are all saddled with Saturday detention. But the detention rapidly evolves into a game of truth or dare forcing the friends to face their true feelings for each other, revealing that sometimes a kiss is just a kiss and sometimes it's more.
- James Van Der Beek as Dawson Leery
- Michelle Williams as Jen Lindley
- Joshua Jackson as Pacey Witter
- Katie Holmes as Joey Potter
- Helen Baldwin as Mrs. Tringle
- Mati Moralejo as Grant Bodian
- Mike Pniewski as Mr. Pickering
- Micah Learner as Daniel
- Barry Bell as Coach
- Linda Bureau as Cheerleader #1
- Adrienne Harvey as Cheerleader #2
- Joey and Dawson share their first kiss.
- Jen and Pacey kiss (for the second time)
- Both Jen and Dawson get jealous.
- Abby announces the elephant in the room – that Joey is in love with Dawson.